Hello dear
Welcome to Arriba Tortilla
Arriba Tortilla, located in East Aurora, NY, is a hidden gem for authentic Mexican cuisine. Known for its expertly crafted dishes like chicken flautas, colossal tamales, and irresistible queso, this establishment delivers a vibrant culinary experience. Customers rave about the impressive portion sizes and unique flavors that elevate traditional favorites. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, complemented by excellent service from staff members like Emily and Bridget, who ensure a memorable dining experience. With quick service and an extensive menu featuring tantalizing options, Arriba Tortilla promises to delight the senses and leave you eager to return.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Taco Family Pack
Burritos
Chile Relleno
Steak Enchilada Flatbread
About
Arriba Tortilla
Welcome to the vibrant world of Arriba Tortilla, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of East Aurora, NY. Located at 40 Riley St, this delightful eatery captures the essence of authentic Mexican cuisine, ensuring that every visit transports you straight to the heart of Mexico. With the warmth of home-cooked meals and the buzz of a lively atmosphere, Arriba Tortilla is a feast for both the senses and the soul.
From patrons like Thomas Zagrobelny, who raves about their fantastic food and quick service, Arriba Tortilla has proven itself to be a favorite among local food enthusiasts. The chicken flautas, complemented by an unforgettable jap jelly, left a lasting impression on many. The dedication to exceptional service, highlighted by staff members like Emily and Bridget, has made dining here feel like a family affair, where every guest is treated with care and kindness.
For lovers of queso, Hanna Marcolina's review resonates as she declares it to be the best she’s ever tasted. This creamy goodness could easily steal the spotlight, especially when paired with their combo sampler platter—a delightful mix that showcases the rich flavors of the menu. It’s no wonder visitors like Lizzie Fi appreciate the huge tamales and monster enchiladas, experience an authenticity unmatched by other establishments.
Arriba Tortilla is not just about food; it's about an experience. As DaveandDeb Albertson pointed out, the ambiance is charming, with a lovely outside dining area that enhances your dining experience. The steak tacos and corn pudding offer distinct flavors that elevate traditional Mexican fare into something extraordinary, making it evident that this is not your average Mexican restaurant.
Regular patrons know they can expect nothing but the best—Dr. Bonnie L. Stafford assures that it never disappoints with its generous portion sizes and delightful menu. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or enjoying a casual meal with loved ones, Arriba Tortilla remains a crowd favorite, perfecting the balance of quality food, exceptional service, and inviting ambience.
With every visit, Arriba Tortilla promises a culinary adventure that leaves you eager for more. So if you find yourself in East Aurora, make sure to pay a visit to this fantastic eatery. You won’t just leave with a full stomach—you’ll also take with you a piece of the warmth and hospitality that makes this place truly special.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ The food was fantastic, perfectly cooked to perfection. I had the chicken flautas, with all the sides on the side. That jap jelly is to die for! The only thing that eclisped the immaculate food, was the service. Our hostess was so quick to seat, get us drinks, and chips and salsa. We felt so at home thanks to the service of, Emily, I think her name was. While no one could even try to follow Emily's service, Bridget waddled along and knocked it out of the park. She was quick, speedy, timely, efficient, kind, compassionate, and above all else, professional. Our food was ordered and brought out within 10-15 minutes, and it was beautiful prepared. Compliments to the chef on that one. Hats off to the owner for cultivating such an amazing experience through great service, great food, and a great atmosphere. I highly recommend requesting either Bridget or Emily if you want fantastic service like I received today. 10/10, would give 6 stars if I could. ”
“ Oh my goodness this queso was the best ever!! I’ve had queso at every Mexican restaurant I’ve been to and this one is the best. I seriously can’t imagine getting queso anywhere else because I’ll be disappointed. We also got the combo sampler platter (forgot what it was called). After filling up on the queso, my husband and I could barely finish it but everything on it was great! We hope to be back ”
“ This place was recommended to us by a couple friends. We were very impressed at the authenticity and ease of ordering. The tamale is HUGE, and ofc so is the monster enchilada. I would deffinetly also recommend the quest dip w chorizo. It hits!! Very very impressed w the food, quick service for such intricate and authentic dishes, and knowledgeable friendly staff. We will be back, Y gracias todos! ”
“ Food is amazing, great service, lovely outside dining area in back. Had Flautas and combo dinner. Steak tacos were delicious. Loved the corn pudding. Great atmosphere, Mexican motif. Bar has nice selection. Easy access. Rear entrance to patio area. Not your average Mexican, different flavors really take the experience to a new level. ”
“ I have been to Arriba many times and it never disappoints. The food is delicious and the portion sizes are huge! I would highly recommend this great East Aurora treasure! ”
“ Consistently good Mexican food for the area. The nachos are to die for, a major recommendation. However they are massive so bring like 5 people. Vegetarian options are readily available. Only possible issue is this place gets busy fast and can have long wait times for both seating and food. I recommend going in off hours. ”
“ Place is very cozy in beautiful town of East aurora. Staff is super friendly. Everything we ordered was great. My favorite was Chicken Flautas. ”
“ I'm not really a fan of mexican food but this place was fabulous. The inside of the restaurant was super cute and clean. The service was very friendly and attentive. Overall, a wonderful experience! The guac was TO DIE FOR (and i don't even like guac)! ”